← Journal Branding

Threads vs X: where should your brand be?

· 4 min read · By the Guruweb team

It's been quite a month for social media.

On 5 July, Meta launched Threads, a text-based app connected to Instagram that looks and feels a lot like Twitter. Because you could sign up with your existing Instagram account in a couple of taps, it passed 100 million sign-ups within about five days, one of the fastest launches of any app.

Then, this past weekend, Elon Musk announced that Twitter was becoming X. By Monday, 24 July, the famous blue bird logo had been replaced with a stark black-and-white X.

So now every brand is asking: should we be on Threads? Should we stay on X? Do we need to be everywhere?

Before we answer that, there's a branding lesson here that's too good to ignore.

The branding lesson: don't throw away what people already know

Think about what Twitter had built over more than fifteen years. The little blue bird was recognised all over the world. The word "tweet" became part of everyday language. People "retweeted" and "went viral on Twitter". News anchors said it. Dictionaries added it.

That's brand equity: the value stored in a name, a symbol and the habits people form around them. It takes years and enormous effort to build. Rebranding to X means starting much of that again from scratch. What do you call a post now? Will people keep saying "tweet" anyway?

Rebrands aren't always a mistake. Sometimes a business has genuinely outgrown its name, merged with another company or needs a fresh start after a crisis. But a rebrand should be a strategic decision with a clear reason, not a change for its own sake.

If you're thinking about rebranding your own business, ask yourself:

  • What do customers already recognise and trust about our current brand?
  • What problem would the rebrand solve? Can we solve it without starting over?
  • Can we evolve rather than replace? A refreshed logo, updated colours or a sharper message can modernise a brand without losing what people already know.
  • How will we bring customers with us? Explain the change clearly and keep the familiar elements where you can.

So, where should your brand be?

New platforms come with a rush of excitement and a fear of missing out. But being everywhere usually means being mediocre everywhere. Use this simple framework instead.

1. Where are your customers?

This is the most important question. Not where the buzz is, but where your customers spend their time and make buying decisions.

Here in Botswana, Facebook and WhatsApp still dominate for most businesses. That's where people ask for recommendations, browse local pages, share specials on their Status and message businesses directly. Instagram matters for visual brands and younger audiences. X has a smaller but often influential crowd, including journalists, professionals and people following news and sport. Threads is brand new, and it's too early to know who will stick around.

If your customers aren't on a platform, it doesn't matter how fast it's growing.

2. Do you have the capacity to post?

Every platform needs regular, quality content and someone to respond to comments and messages. An abandoned account with its last post from months ago does more harm than having no account at all.

Be honest: can you realistically keep up with another platform? If not, do one or two platforms well.

3. What type of content do you create?

Match the platform to your strengths:

Your content Where it fits best
Photos of products, food, fashion, spaces Instagram, Facebook
Short videos Instagram Reels, TikTok, Facebook
Opinions, news, quick updates, conversation X, Threads
Specials, direct orders, customer service WhatsApp, Facebook
Professional insight, B2B services LinkedIn

4. What's your goal?

Awareness, sales, customer service, reputation or recruitment? Different platforms serve different goals. Decide what you want first, then choose the channel.

Our advice right now

  • Claim your name on Threads. It costs nothing to reserve your brand's handle so nobody else takes it. If you're already active on Instagram, you can experiment there at very little cost.
  • Don't abandon what works. If X brings you customers, stay. If it never did, this is a good moment to stop spreading yourself thin.
  • Double down on Facebook and WhatsApp if that's where your customers are, and for most Botswana businesses, it is.
  • Keep building owned channels. Platforms change names, owners and rules. Your website and customer list are yours. We made this case when Twitter changed hands last year: don't build your business on rented land.

Conclusion

New apps will keep arriving and old ones will keep changing. A strong brand isn't defined by which platforms it's on, but by how clearly and consistently it shows up wherever its customers are. Choose your platforms deliberately, protect the brand equity you've built, and don't chase every shiny new thing.

Need help building a brand that stays recognisable on every platform, now and through whatever comes next?

Learn More >>

Want help putting this into practice?

Book a free 15-minute chat and we’ll show you the simplest next step for your business.

Let’s talk